Saturday, January 28, 2012

Ah science!


Galileo's excision of God from the world of matter mirrored the even more audacious banishment of subjective experiences from the domain of rigorous intellectual exploration.
.
Not only their knowability was questioned, but even their reality.
.
Science is the study of reality
.
What is not measurable is not a valid subject of science.
.
Therefore what is not measurable is not real.
.
A century later, David Hume took up this position with great enthusiasm:
.
Let us ask,
.
Does it contain any abstract reasoning concerning quantity or number?
.
No.
.
Does it contain any experimental reasoning concerning matter of fact and existence?
.
No.
.
Commit it then to the flames; for it contains nothing but sophistry and illusion.
.
Ironic indeed, then, is the present state of science,
.
In which once again vast areas of inquiry are off-limits.
.
In which experimental results that contradict orthodoxy are excluded from publication.
.
In which knowledge is restricted to those initiated into the language of its abstruse texts.
.
In which whole fields wallow in fruitless hyperspecialization.
.
In which the public can only await the pronouncements of this new quasi-ecclesiastical hierarchy.
.
Holder of the keys to the gates of knowledge.
.
Can we say that we have not replicated the old world within the new?
.
Upon the Scientific Method, which freed thought from the institutionalized, authoritarian superstition of the Middle Ages.
.
We have built yet a new orthodoxy.
.
More totalitarian, if more subtle, than the first.
.
Charles Eisenstein

No comments: